Husqvarna vs John Deere Lawn Mowers & Garden Tractors Specs Comparison

Both Husqvarna and John Deere are well-known brands in the lawn mower industry, each with its own reputation for reliability. The reliability of a lawn mower can depend on various factors, including the specific model, maintenance practices, and individual experiences.

Ultimately, the choice between Husqvarna and John Deere may come down to personal preference, specific requirements, and budget. It’s essential to research and compare the features, specifications, and reviews of individual models from both brands to determine which one best suits your needs and offers the reliability you’re looking for. Additionally, factors such as dealer support and availability of service may also influence your decision.

Zero-Turn Mowers: John Deere Z320R vs Husqvarna Z242F

John Deere Z320R

Z320R Zero-Turn Mower Pros:

• Accel Deep™ Mower Deck: Features a 42-inch Accel Deep™ Mower Deck for efficient cutting and discharge.
• Reliable Engine: Equipped with a Kawasaki FR651V engine delivering 21.5 horsepower for consistent performance.
• Hydrostatic Drive: Utilizes a Hydro-Gear hydrostatic drive system for smooth and precise control.
• Wide Range of Cut Heights: Offers a wide range of cut heights from 1.25 to 4.5 inches, allowing for versatile mowing.
• Foot Lift System: Features a foot-operated lift system for convenient adjustment of the mower deck.

Z320R Zero-Turn Mower Cons:

• No ROPS: Lacks a Roll-Over Protection System (ROPS), potentially limiting safety features in certain environments.
• Manual Cut Height Adjustment: Requires manual, hand-operated adjustment for the mower cut height, which may be less convenient compared to other systems.
• Warranty Limitation: Although offering a 3-year or 200-hour warranty, some competitors may provide longer warranty coverage.
• Limited Height: Taller operators may find the mower’s height of 43.3 inches less comfortable during operation.
• Higher Weight: Weighing 572 pounds, it may be slightly heavier than comparable models, potentially impacting maneuverability.

Husqvarna Z242F

Z242F Zero-Turn Mower Pros:

• Deck: Features a 42-inch ClearCut™ Fabricated Deck for superior cutting performance and durability.
• Powerful Engine: Equipped with a Kawasaki FR730V engine delivering 21.5 horsepower, ensuring reliable and consistent power.
• Hydrostatic Drive: Utilizes a Hydro-Gear hydrostatic drive system for smooth and responsive operation.
• Wide Range of Cut Heights: Offers a range of cut heights from 1.5 to 4.0 inches, providing flexibility for different grass lengths.
• Pneumatic Tires: Equipped with pneumatic front caster and drive tires for improved traction and maneuverability.

Z242F Zero-Turn Mower Cons:

• No ROPS: Similar to the John Deere model, it lacks a Roll-Over Protection System (ROPS), potentially impacting safety.
• Manual Cut Height Adjustment: Requires manual, hand-operated adjustment for the mower cut height, which may be less convenient for some users.
• Shorter Warranty: Offers a 2-year domestic warranty, providing shorter coverage compared to some competitors.
• Lower Height: With a height of 40 inches, taller operators may find it less comfortable to operate for extended periods.
• Comparable Weight: Although slightly lighter at 566 pounds, it remains relatively heavy, potentially affecting maneuverability and transport.

Lawn Tractors: John Deere S100 vs Husqvarna YTH1942

John Deere S100

S100 Lawn Tractor Pros:

• Spring-assisted hand-grip lever lift system for easy adjustment of the mower deck height.
• Hydrostatic drive type offers smooth operation and easy speed control.
• Compact size and design make it suitable for maneuvering around obstacles in smaller yards.
• Briggs & Stratton engine known for reliability and performance.
• Offers 13 cutting height positions for precise lawn grooming.
• Lightweight compared to the Husqvarna YTH1942, making it easier to transport and maneuver.
• Comes with a 2-year / 120-hour bumper-to-bumper warranty for peace of mind.

S100 Lawn Tractor Cons:

• Lower engine power (17.5 hp) compared to the Husqvarna YTH1942.
• Slightly lower maximum forward and reverse speeds compared to the Husqvarna model.
• May not be as suitable for larger properties due to its smaller size and engine power.

Husqvarna YTH1942

YTH1942 Lawn Tractor Pros:

• More powerful Briggs & Stratton engine (19.0 hp) for enhanced performance and cutting efficiency.
• Hand-operated deck lift system allows for quick and easy adjustment of the mower deck height.
• Hydrostatic drive type ensures smooth operation and precise speed control.
• Air Induction™ Reinforced Steel Deck provides superior cutting performance and durability.
• Offers 6 cutting height positions with larger increments for convenient adjustment.
• Larger dimensions and heavier weight contribute to stability and durability.
• Comes with a 3-year bumper-to-bumper warranty, offering longer coverage compared to the John Deere S100.

YTH1942 Lawn Tractor Cons:

• Heavier weight may make it slightly more difficult to transport and maneuver compared to the John Deere S100.
• Limited to 6 cutting height positions, which may not offer as much precision as the John Deere S100’s 13 positions.
• Slightly lower maximum forward and reverse speeds compared to the John Deere model.
• Warranty limited to residential use only, whereas the John Deere S100 offers warranty for residential and commercial use.

Robotic Mowers: John Deere Tango E5 vs Husqvarna Automower 450XH

John Deere Tango E5

Tango E5 Robotic Mower Pros:

• Compact Size: Smaller dimensions make it suitable for tighter spaces and storage.
• Quieter Operation: Lower sound level at 62.2 dB(A), making it less intrusive during operation.
• Faster Charging: Shorter charging time of 80 minutes for quicker turnaround between mowing sessions.
• Longer Warranty: Offers a 3-year or 200-hour warranty, providing extended coverage and peace of mind.
• Easy Navigation: Utilizes random pattern navigation with specific start zones, simplifying setup and operation.

Tango E5 Robotic Mower Cons:

• Limited Lawn Size Capacity: Suitable for smaller lawns up to 0.54 acres (2,200 m2), may not be suitable for larger properties.
• Shorter Mowing Time: 90 minutes of mowing time with one battery load may require multiple charging cycles for larger areas.
• Smaller Cutting Width: Narrower cutting width of 8.0 inches (203 mm) may result in longer mowing times for larger lawns.
• Lower Battery Capacity: Smaller battery capacity of 4 Ah may require more frequent charging compared to models with higher capacities.
• Basic Display: MonoChrome display may offer less intuitive user interface compared to models with graphical displays.

Husqvarna Automower 450XH

Automower 450XH Robotic Mower Pros:

• Extended Lawn Size Capacity: Suitable for larger properties up to 2.5 acres (10,100 m2), offering versatility for expansive lawns.
• Longer Mowing Time: Extended mowing time of 200 minutes with one battery load allows for more coverage before recharging.
• Faster Charging: Shorter charging time of 60 minutes for quicker turnaround between mowing cycles.
• Higher Cutting Width: Wider cutting width of 9.45 inches (240 mm) enables faster mowing of larger areas.
• Advanced Navigation: Utilizes satellite-based Husqvarna EPOS™ Technology for precise and efficient navigation.

Automower 450XH Robotic Mower Cons:

• Larger Size: Bulkier dimensions may be less maneuverable in tight spaces and require more storage space.
• Higher Sound Level: Louder operation at 68 dB(A) may be more noticeable during mowing sessions.
• Shorter Warranty: Offers a 2-year domestic warranty, providing shorter coverage compared to some competitors.
• Higher Weight: Heavier weight of 34.6 lbs (15.7 kg) may result in increased wear on the lawn over time.
• Advanced Features: Advanced navigation technology may come with a steeper learning curve for setup and operation.

Which Brand is Better?

Consumer complaints about John Deere and Husqvarna lawn mowers can vary based on individual experiences and specific models. However, some common complaints for each brand might include:

John Deere Mowers

1. Price: Some consumers may find John Deere mowers to be more expensive compared to other brands, which can be a point of contention for budget-conscious buyers.
2. Durability: While John Deere is generally known for its durability and quality construction, some consumers may have experienced issues with certain models, such as components wearing out prematurely or needing frequent repairs.
3. Service and Support: There have been occasional complaints about difficulties in obtaining timely service or support from John Deere dealerships, especially in rural areas where dealerships may be scarce.
4. Complexity: Certain John Deere models, particularly those with advanced features or technology, may have a steeper learning curve for operation and maintenance, leading to frustration for some users.
5. Availability of Parts: In some cases, consumers may have encountered challenges in finding replacement parts for older John Deere models, especially those that are no longer in production.

Husqvarna Mowers:

1. Cutting Quality: While Husqvarna mowers generally provide a high-quality cut, some consumers have reported issues with uneven cutting or scalping, particularly on uneven terrain or when operating at higher speeds.
2. Durability of Components: Like any brand, Husqvarna mowers can experience component failures or wear over time. Some users have reported issues with belts, pulleys, or other components needing replacement sooner than expected.
3. Customer Service: While Husqvarna typically offers good customer service, there have been occasional complaints about long wait times for support or difficulty in reaching knowledgeable representatives.
4. Transmission Issues: A few consumers have reported problems with the hydrostatic transmissions on certain Husqvarna models, such as loss of power or difficulty shifting gears.
5. Mulching Performance: Some users have noted that Husqvarna mowers may not mulch grass clippings as effectively as they would like, leading to accumulation of clippings on the lawn or uneven distribution.

It’s important to note that both John Deere and Husqvarna produce a wide range of lawn mower models, and individual experiences can vary widely depending on factors such as usage, maintenance, and specific model features.

2023 Lawn Tractors Ratings by CR.org

Whether you prioritize overall score, predicted reliability, or specific functionalities like side discharging, mulching, or bagging, CR.org’s ratings help you make informed decisions to achieve the perfect cut for your lawn.

Consumer Reports is an independent, nonprofit organization that works side by side with consumers for truth, transparency, and fairness in the marketplace. For complete reviews, articles, tips and recommendations go to ConsumerReports.org to become a member.